How It Works
ContactLog in
Estate & Loss

The Auction Comp Said $672. We Asked $1,500. It Sold for $1,440.

November 18, 2026

A signed Michael Aram skeleton chair from a Matthews, North Carolina storage unit, photographed before it sold

Free On-Site WalkthroughWritten Plan Within one business dayItemized Proposal Before Any WorkYou Keep 85% Of Every Sale, After Marketplace Fees

If you are settling an estate and one piece looks better than the rest, the question is whether to price it to sell this week or price it for what it is. Our answer, from a chair we sold on November 17: price it for what it is, but only once you can prove what it is, and only if you know what the wait will cost you.

What Came Out of the Storage Unit?

In October I walked a storage unit in Matthews for the people settling an estate. It was packed to the door. The furniture was at the back, behind the art, and one of the pieces was a metal chair shaped like a human skeleton. They believed it was by Michael Aram, the metalwork designer.

Believing is not the same as knowing. There was no label and no paperwork.

What Did the Sold Prices Say?

I look for sold prices before asking prices, because an asking price is only somebody's hope. For this chair I found one auction result, from 2022: about $672 for a single chair.

One result is thin. It tells you what one room of bidders paid on one afternoon. It does not tell you what a private buyer who has been looking for that exact chair will pay.

Why Did We Ask More Than Twice the Comp?

We listed the chair on October 22 with an asking price of $1,500. That is more than twice the only comparable sale, and I knew it.

The reasoning was this. An auction result is close to a floor, because the piece has to sell that day to whoever is in the room. A listing can wait for its buyer. But a listing at that price only works if the buyer can see proof, and on October 22 we had none.

So the price came with a condition I set for myself: go back and find the signature, or bring the price down to the comp.

What Changed on the Next Visit?

Two days later I was back in the unit. With the chair pulled into the light, there was a signature scratched into the metal in script. I photographed it close and added the photograph to the listing. The description changed from a seller's attribution to one word: signed. We did not authenticate the chair and the listing never said we had. It showed the mark and let the buyer judge.

The price stayed where it was.

What Did the Wait Cost?

The chair sold on November 17 for $1,440, sixty dollars under the asking price, and shipped to New York. That is 26 days after it went on sale.

Twenty-six days is the cost. Here it was affordable: the chair sat in storage with the rest of the estate while other pieces sold around it. In a house that has to be empty for a closing in two weeks, the same decision could easily have been wrong. Priced at the comp, the chair would likely have sold sooner, for less than half.

What Would I Do Differently?

Photograph the signature on the first visit. For two days the listing asked a signed-piece price with no signature to show. The same lesson came out of this unit twice: another chair we had taken for one maker turned out, from the tag under the seat, to be by a different one.

How Do You Use This on Your Own Estate?

Most of what is in a house should be priced to move. A few pieces should not, and the work is telling them apart. Look for a mark, a label or a signature before you look for a price. Treat a single auction result as the least the piece is worth, not the most. And decide in advance how long you can afford to wait. Our guide to valuing the contents of an estate without an appraiser covers the method for everything else in the house.

If you are doing this from another state, send us photographs and we will tell you which pieces are worth the wait. If you would rather check one piece yourself first, the free item scan gives a first read from a photo. For a local estate we start with a free walkthrough and a written quote before any work, and our commission is 15% of what an item sells for after marketplace fees. Our estate valuation service for executors explains how that works. Recent results are on the sold page, and what is for sale now is at vaultxlshop.com.

This is general information from our own work, not an appraisal and not legal or tax advice.

Additional Resources

Not sure which pieces deserve a real price?

Photograph one item and get an identification and current asking prices by email. One free scan per person, no card.

Or call us: (704) 975-1405

“What particularly impressed me was his sophisticated approach to consignment. He uses industry-leading tools and market data to determine appropriate pricing and product placement rather than simply guessing at what an item might bring. My two most expensive items were sold quickly, professionally, and securely. Consigning valuable belongings can require a significant amount of trust, and Charles earned mine very quickly.”

D.C. · Charlotte, NC

Free On-Site WalkthroughWritten Plan Within one business dayItemized Proposal Before Any WorkYou Keep 85% Of Every Sale, After Marketplace Fees
Call NowFree Consultation